Comparisons
PagerDuty alternatives: what to evaluate and who to consider
Comparisons · Updated 2026-10-19 · 10 min read · By the CallHeim team
Teams look for a PagerDuty alternative for three recurring reasons: the per-seat price climbs fast once you add the features you actually need, several capabilities (like alert grouping) are sold as separate add-ons, and some teams simply want a smaller, more explainable tool than an incident-response platform built for large enterprises. The main options are CallHeim, Splunk On-Call, SolarWinds Incident Response, Rootly and incident.io. Below is what to evaluate, how the field splits, and where CallHeim fits.
Competitor information last verified October 2026. Sources are linked beside each fact.
Why teams start looking
PagerDuty lists a Free plan (up to 5 users) and a Professional plan at $25 per user per month, or $21 on an annual plan. Larger deployments are sold as the PD Reliability Platform, an annual platform fee that includes seats. (PagerDuty pricing page, checked 2026-10-19) Professional includes an external status page for up to 250 subscribers, with 2 teams and 2 predefined incident roles. (PagerDuty pricing page, checked 2026-10-19)
The add-ons compound the price: the AIOps add-on for alert grouping starts at $699 a month on an annual plan ($799 billed monthly), priced per accepted event and needing at least one paid Incident Management user. (PagerDuty AIOps pricing page, checked 2026-10-19) A separate Advance add-on starts at $415 a month with an annual commitment. (PagerDuty AIOps pricing page, checked 2026-10-19) See our full breakdown of PagerDuty pricing by plan, including a worked example of how the seat cost scales with headcount.
The “explainable grouping” question is specific: PagerDuty documents four alert-grouping methods — Intelligent, Alert Content, Intelligent plus Alert Content, and Time only — and grouping comes with the AIOps add-on or the Reliability Platform plans. (PagerDuty alert grouping documentation, checked 2026-10-19) A team that wants grouping without a separate line item, or wants to read exactly why two alerts were grouped, is often the team that starts comparing alternatives.
Simplicity is the least quantifiable of the reasons but often the deciding one. PagerDuty covers incident management for organizations with many teams, many services and layered admin controls, and that breadth shows up in the product even for a team that only needs a handful of schedules and one escalation policy. A smaller team can find itself paying for, and configuring around, capability it will never use — which is a legitimate reason to look at a narrower, more purpose-built tool.
What to evaluate before you switch
Whatever you replace PagerDuty with, the same checklist applies — and it is worth scoring your current PagerDuty usage against it first, so you know which rows actually matter to your team rather than which ones sound important in a vendor’s marketing:
- Alert handling and explainability. Whether you can read exactly why an alert paged someone, or why a repeat was grouped instead, rather than trusting an opaque score.
- Escalation. How many tiers a policy can have, how per-tier timeouts work, and what happens when nobody acknowledges.
- Incident workflow. How an incident moves from triggered to acknowledged to resolved, and what its timeline records along the way.
- Integrations. Whether your specific monitoring tools have a documented payload mapping and setup guide, not just a generic inbound webhook you have to map yourself.
- Migration effort. Whether schedules, escalation policies and incident history actually import, or need rebuilding from scratch.
- Pricing. The seat price, what is bundled at that tier, and what is sold as a separate add-on on top of it.
- Auditability. Whether configuration changes are recorded with before-and-after values in an append-only audit log.
- Operational visibility. Whether acknowledgment and resolution times, alert volume by source and schedule coverage gaps are visible without an add-on.
Hypothetical example. A 20-person platform team on PagerDuty Professional, paying for the AIOps add-on because on-call has quietly become “whoever is awake gets paged thirty times a night.” Running the checklist: escalation is not the gap — the team’s escalation policies already route pages correctly. Migration effort is the real unknown, because the team has six schedules with two years of overrides layered on top, and any tool’s importer needs to be checked against exactly that configuration, not a demo account. Pricing is the immediate driver: dropping the $699-a-month AIOps floor (PagerDuty AIOps pricing page, checked 2026-10-19) by moving noise handling into the base seat price is worth more to this team than a small per-seat discount on its own — which is a conclusion the checklist reaches before a single vendor demo.
The alternatives, named
Opsgenie (Atlassian) is not an option for a new customer. Atlassian stopped selling Opsgenie on 4 June 2025. Opsgenie reaches end of support on 5 April 2027: access is shut off and customer data that has not been moved is deleted, so move or export what you need before then. (Atlassian’s Opsgenie licensing page, checked 2026-10-19) If you are already on Atlassian and want to stay in that ecosystem, Jira Service Management is Atlassian’s named successor product. See our Opsgenie end-of-support guide for the full timeline.
Grafana OnCall, the open-source project, entered maintenance mode on 11 March 2025 and was archived on 24 March 2026; once archived, its cloud-connected notifications stop working. (Grafana OnCall maintenance-mode announcement, checked 2026-10-19) Grafana’s recommended successor, Cloud IRM, has a free tier limited to three active users a month. (Grafana pricing page, checked 2026-10-19) Above that, Pro is priced at $20 per active user plus a $19-a-month platform fee that covers the first three users, and a custom Enterprise tier carries a $25,000 minimum annual commitment. (Grafana pricing page, checked 2026-10-19)
The rest of the field splits roughly into two groups: dedicated on-call products with straightforward per-seat pricing (CallHeim, Splunk On-Call, SolarWinds Incident Response), and a newer wave of incident-response platforms that sell on-call as part of a broader incident-management product, sometimes as a separate add-on to a base seat (Rootly, incident.io). Neither group is inherently better — which one fits depends on whether you want on-call alone or on-call bundled with post-incident tooling like retrospectives and status communications.
| Vendor | Starting price (as published) | One thing to know |
|---|---|---|
| CallHeim | Starter $9, Pro $15, Business $29 per user per month | Rule-based alert handling you can read end to end, with noise handling and core analytics in every plan. |
| Splunk On-Call | From $5/user/month on an annual plan, up to 10 seats | A dedicated on-call product with per-seat pricing. Splunk pricing page |
| SolarWinds Incident Response | $15/user/month, unlimited users | Formerly Squadcast; SolarWinds announced the acquisition on 3 March 2025. SolarWinds Incident Response product page |
| Rootly | $20/user/month per product (Incident Response; On-Call) | Incident Response and On-Call are separate products; status pages come with Incident Response. Rootly pricing page |
| incident.io | Free Basic plan with single-team on-call; Team $19 ($15 annual) and Pro $25 per user | Multi-team on-call is a per-user add-on ($10 on Team, $20 on Pro). incident.io pricing page |
Competitor figures checked against each vendor’s own page; re-verify before you budget, since list prices move. The vendors’ plans bundle different capabilities, so compare what each plan includes, not the headline rate alone.
Choosing among them
A few starting questions narrow the field faster than reading every pricing page in order. If on-call is your whole problem — not incident retrospectives, not status communications — a dedicated on-call product with a per-seat price avoids paying for a broader platform you will only use part of. CallHeim, Splunk On-Call and SolarWinds Incident Response are built that way. If you want incident response and on-call together and are comfortable with an add-on-priced model, Rootly and incident.io are both built that way. If you are already inside the Atlassian suite, Jira Service Management is Atlassian’s named successor to Opsgenie. And if explainable, rule-based alert handling and transparent per-seat pricing matter most to you, that is what CallHeim is built for — described below. If you want the row-by-row detail, see the full CallHeim vs PagerDuty comparison.
How CallHeim handles this
CallHeim’s alert handling is rule-based and deterministic: given the same alert, settings and state, it makes the same decision.
The rules behind the noise handling are published. A repeat attaches to its open incident, within 24 hours of the incident opening unless the sender supplies its own dedup key. A series that changes state 4 times in 600 seconds is treated as flapping. Near-identical titles from the same source and service group together at a similarity of 0.6. Title grouping can be switched off for your organization.
Starter $9, Pro $15 and Business $29 per user per month. Enterprise is negotiated. 14-day trial for up to 5 seats, no card required. Full plan details are on CallHeim’s pricing page.
The importer reads your PagerDuty or Opsgenie configuration from a US or EU account, and a dry run shows you the result before anything is written to your organization. Incident pages go out by e-mail on every plan, each with a signed acknowledge link, and sent, delivered and bounced status is recorded on the incident. Pages can also go out by push, text message and phone call. See how it works on the platform overview before you evaluate further.
Key takeaways
- PagerDuty lists Free and Professional per-seat plans and sells larger deployments as the PD Reliability Platform; alert grouping comes with the AIOps add-on or the Reliability Platform plans.
- Evaluate any alternative on the same eight criteria: alert handling and explainability, escalation, incident workflow, integrations, migration effort, pricing, auditability and operational visibility.
- Opsgenie cannot be purchased by new customers; Grafana OnCall’s open-source project is archived, with Cloud IRM as the paid successor.
- Splunk On-Call, SolarWinds Incident Response, Rootly and incident.io each publish a different pricing shape — per seat, per product or with a separate on-call add-on.
- CallHeim offers rule-based alert handling, flat per-seat pricing and an importer for PagerDuty configuration.
Questions
Common questions, answered.
What is the best PagerDuty alternative?
There is no single best answer — it depends which of the eight criteria above your team weighs most. A team with a specific channel or identity requirement needs a different answer than one mainly trying to drop an AIOps-style add-on cost. Score your own PagerDuty usage against the checklist first, then compare the two or three vendors that still fit.
Is CallHeim a good PagerDuty alternative?
CallHeim’s alert handling is rule-based and deterministic: given the same alert, settings and state, it makes the same decision. Starter $9, Pro $15 and Business $29 per user per month. Enterprise is negotiated. Paid plans are invoiced and activated directly by the CallHeim team; ask from Billing in the app. The pricing page lists what each plan includes.
Can I migrate my PagerDuty schedules and escalation policies to CallHeim?
Yes. The importer reads your PagerDuty configuration, in a US or EU region account, and a dry run lets you review the result before anything is written to your organization. Escalation-policy tiers import with every user, schedule and team target of each tier, and schedules import with their layers, restrictions and upcoming overrides. Compare both with the originals after import.
Does alert grouping require a paid add-on everywhere?
At PagerDuty, grouping comes with the AIOps add-on or the PD Reliability Platform plans. Other vendors vary: check whether noise reduction is bundled into the base seat price or sold separately before comparing headline prices across vendors.
Which PagerDuty alternative is cheapest?
It depends what you need bundled at that price. A lower seat price with alert grouping or analytics sold separately can cost more once you add the pieces your team needs, so compare the whole bill: seat price, add-ons and seat limits. CallHeim lists Starter $9, Pro $15 and Business $29 per user per month, with noise handling and core analytics in every plan.
Is Opsgenie still a PagerDuty alternative?
Not for a new customer: Atlassian no longer sells Opsgenie. The Opsgenie end-of-support guide has the dates and a planning checklist for teams already on it.
Try it
See this in your own on-call rotation.
14-day trial for up to 5 seats, no card required.